HINDU ETHICS
Ethics are standards of conduct and
moral judgment prevalent in a society. While laws are
imposed by governments by external force, ethics are
self-imposed by individuals through their inner or moral
strength (Greek ithikos or moral) and make up the
character (or ethos, the Greek term for character) of
the members of that society. Ethical conduct or
dharma, and not dogma or creed is the core of
Hinduism, as reflected in the Hindu name for religion,
dharma or righteous conduct. Manu says aachaarah
parmo dharmah – righteous conduct is the highest
dharma. Righteous conduct or samanya dharma
sustains the outer world order while yoga, ishwar
stuti, prathana, and upaasna sustain order in
the inner world. Dharma is what distinguishes us from
animals and a person without dharma is like an animal. (dharmen
heenah pashubhih samaanah)
If ethical conduct is the essence of
Hinduism, we as Hindus need to study how ideal conduct
has been defined in Hinduism. Is it the mere following
of prevalent customs and habits (as more, the
Latin root of moral, would word indicates), or doing
whatever anything useful that serves some purpose (as
gut, the German root of the word good, would
suggest) for us and our children, or to act by certain
prescribed standard of right or wrong that sets us apart
as Hindus (as rectus, the Latin root of the word
right, would suggest)? Is Hindu dharma synonymous with
humanism or merely a pragmatic way of life, a common
cliché of middle class Hindus, or are there distinctive
behavioral or ethical guidelines that guide us as
Hindus?
Swami Dayananda defined dharma as the
just and righteous way of living as taught by the Vedas
and smritis. Vedas and Upanishads state the
overarching principles of virtuous behavior; the smritis
such as the dharma shastras of Manu and Yajvalkya
operationalize these principles into a detailed code of
conduct. Vidur Niti and Shanti Parva of Mahabharata, the
tenth and twelfth chapter of Bhagavad Gita, and the Niti
Sholkas also describe virtuous behavior in detail.
Ramayana, too, has advice about righteous conduct at
many places. However, discussion of all these books is
beyond the scope of this article and the following
discussion will be based upon a famous shloka
that lists ten signs of dharma.
Dhriti, kshama, daamo, asteyam,
shaucham, indriya nigrah, dhih, vidya,satyam,akrodhah,
dashkum dharmam lakshnam.
Patience, forgiveness, restraint, non-stealing,
keeping body and mind clean, controlling the senses,
acquiring knowledge and wisdom, truthfulness, and not
being angry are the ten signs of dharma.
Satyam or truthfulness is considered to be the king
of virtues in Hinduism. In our daily prayers we pray to
God to lead us from falsehood to truth. (asato ma
sadgamaya) Satyam iva jaayte (Only truth is
victorious) is enshrined in the national emblem of
India. Guru Nanak equated truth with God. Despite its
top rank in the list of Hindu virtues, satya is often
not upheld in our daily conduct. In fact it was
difficult to uphold absolute truth even for Lord Krishna
who lied about the death of Ashwathama in Mahabharata.
Telling a lie to save an innocent life is condoned in
Hinduism. The parable of a monk who lied to a band of
robbers to save a farmer’s life is well known. Bhagawana
Krishna lied to defeat the forces of evil in
Mahabharata. But these well intentioned lies should not
be used to rationalize the common lies that are rife in
our lives. Economic or political expediency, fear, and
lack of straightforwardness are a few reasons for
telling lies. Many people tell lies to the taxman;
businessmen tell lies to flaunt their products,
politicians tell lies to get elected or to promote their
point of view. Many well-intentioned people lie to their
loved ones instead of giving a bad news to them. In our
community we do not tell our parents or children if they
or we have a fatal disease. We even avoid telling the
truth to our friends for fear of offending them. People
tell lies about their wealth to avoid an evil eye.
However, Bhagawana Krishna considers arjava or
straightforwardness to be a virtue dear to him. Swami
Dayananda also recommends that we should call a spade a
spade, although gently. If we do not give proper
feedback to our friends just for fear of offending them,
they will be in dark and will not be able to rectify
their mistake thus losing in the long run. The Vedas
want us to be fearless, Abhayam mitrad abhyam amitrad
abhyam gyatad abhyam puo nah. Even in the matter of
a fatal disease the person who is sick will sense that
something or wrong but stay in dark and fantasize. Thus
the only time Hinduism condones a lie is if telling the
truth will jeopardize the life of an innocent person.
Rest should be considered moral relativism and
hypocrisy.
Patience or dhritih is the ability to wait
patiently for results of our karma. All endeavors
require effort and take time to fruition. Ramayana says
that samay paye taruvar khile ketic seencho neer-
a tree takes time to grow even if you water it
continuously. A farmer has to wait for winter or his
crops to mature; a student waits for the whole year
before he knows the results of his studies. Many a crime
are committed by people who want to make a quick buck.
Modern psychology considers the ability to delay
gratification an important executive function of the
brain that we acquire as we develop from infancy to
adulthood. Impatience is a key feature of the common
condition of attention deficit hyperactivity disorder. A
Christian prayer says, "O Lord! Be thou the guide that
we with patience may run the race which is set before
us." Obsession or raga with results destroys the karma
phal according to Gita. Fear of not achieving our
goals causes anxiety, stress, and depression and is
counterproductive. The virtue of santosh or
contentment is closely related to dhriti because
one who is content and at peace with his current state
is unlikely to be anxious or impatient. So let us do our
assigned duty or niyatam karma for duty’s sake,
and not be obsessed with results. Let us be content
without being complacent or stagnant.
Forgiveness or kshama has a
high rank in the Hindu book of virtues. By forgiving our
friends and family for their mistakes or misdemeanors,
we can avoid ruminating over the hurt they caused and go
on with our lives. Lack of forgiveness festers like a
sore eating up the peace of our mind. Forgiveness
liberates us from anger and dvesha. Many wars
could be avoided if only the nations could forgive other
nations for their past mistakes. The vicious cycle of
revenge that is ravaging the Middle East and the whole
world can only be broken if one party forgives the
other. Lord Rama showed us the way in Ramayana when he
forgave his step mother Kaikaeyi for banishing him to
the jungle. Swami Dayananda not only forgave his killer
but gave him money to escape. Lord Krishna says that a
virtuous person is similar to friend and foe, same in
honor and dishonor (samah shatrau cha mitre, maan
apmaanayoh), is free from hatred for any creature (adveshta
sarva bhutanaam), and is friendly and compassionate
(maitrah karun ava cha). Let us all understand
friends and strangers and be forgiving. (sam gyanam,
nah savaebhi, sam gyanam arnebhi). Let the noise of
wanton slaughter not rise amongst us. (Maa ghosa ut
sthu bahule vianirhate) Atharveda (VII.54.1-2)
Damah mean self control or restraint. The
meaning of the word religion is restraint; therefore,
restraint is the very essence of religion. According to
Sigmund Freud, the great psychologist, we are born with
id or innate drives of aggression and sexuality. As we
grow we develop the ability to rein in these drives by
building our conscience or superego. The process of
control over one’s senses; or indriya nigrah is a
component of this virtue of damah. We are
supposed to exercise self control in pursuit of sensual
pleasures (brhamcharya), in amassing wealth (aparigrah),
and in expressing joy and sorrow (samata). Lord
Krishna considers austerity (tapah) as an
essential character of a devotee dear to him. Vedas call
upon men and women to be hard-working and formidable (ugram)
in confronting and overcoming difficulties and
challenges. Fasting (upvaasa) and practice of silence (maunam)
were used by devout Hindus to acquire self control or
damah. This constant exercise of restraint distinguishes
us from the western cultural ethic of exuberance,
extravagance, and wanton consumerism.
Non-stealing or asteyam is self-explanatory
but stealing can be overt or covert. Corruption is a
form of stealing from the rightful, stealing from the
employer, stealing by cheating in the stores, stealing
from the taxman. In fact, we should be willing to give
up personal possessions for others (tyaag and
daanam) in need.
Shaucham as cleanliness of the body is self
evident, but the cleanliness of the thoughts, or manner
of speaking, and of the soul is subtle and difficult to
attain. Cleanliness of the thought includes freedom form
envy, jealousy, and judgment. Envy and jealously
are a cardinal sin in Christianity. In Athraveda the
mind of the jealous is said to be more lifeless than the
earth and a dead person (yatha bhumih mritmanah
mritaat mritmanah tara. Yatha ut mamrushah manah aiva
irshyo mrtiam mananh). (VI.18.2.3) and the devotee
prays to God to relinquish jealously as heat is
relinquished by the bellows. (tatah te irshyam
munchaami nih ushmanam driteh iva) Unless we clean
our mind of these evil tendencies (duritani
paraasuava) we cannot accomplish the goal of
shaucham. Cleanliness of the vaani or speech
is in talking sweetly and gently. (vaacaum nah
svadatu). Cleanliness of the body is done through
asanas and pranayama and cleanliness of the soul though
meditation. The latter takes practice or abhyasa
of a lifetime and one needs dhritih or patience
to accomplish, just as a dirty pot takes a lot of effort
to clean.
Absence of anger or akrodhah,is
a high virtue in Hinduism. Bhagwan Krishna says in Gita
that anger causes loss of memory and loss of memory, in
turn, leads to loss of intelligence. He wants calmness
of the mind (Shamah) in persons who are dear to
him. If we are broadminded (Brihta) and
have the right attitude (Ritam), as
recommended in Atharveda, we will not be angry.
Everyone is fallible and can make a mistake. Anger
occurs when we fail to forgive others (kshama)
for their transgressions. If we have cultivate
compassion (karuna) and friendliness (maitri)
for all we will not be angry. Krodh is actually a form
of violence. Thus anger (krodh) and nonviolence
(Ahimsa) are mutually exclusive. However,
Hinduism allows one to have rightful wrath or manyu
when one sees injustice. We pray to the Lord to give us
a powerful personality (tejah) that can fight
injustice, but without arrogance (dambha) and
false pride (mad).
Acquiring knowledge and wisdom (vidya and dhi)
are considered to be high virtues in Hinduism. Swami
Dayananda made it an article of faith of Arya Samaj.
According to him, most of the problems of the world
would be solved if we remove ignorance, acquire
knowledge and than act according to what we leaned to be
true. According to Taittiriya Upanishad, aptitude for
learning (Brahman), self study (Svadhyaya),
and listening to religious discourse (Pravachana)
are essential for every true seeker. However, according
to swami Dayananda, mere knowledge without discernment
is the payload of a donkey. And that is the take home
message of this article. Practice what you learn. Do
manan after shravan and then do grihan.
Let us hope that once we acquire the above virtues (tada
bhadram tanna aasuva), we will become arya or
noble.