Gita is a lyrical discourse in which
the author, as Lord Krishna, in first person, exhorts
Arjuna, the quintessential man, to perform his assigned
(or chosen) duty efficiently. Through the allegory of a
mythical war between Arjuna and his first cousins the
author refers to the battle of life. In life we are
often faced with moral dilemmas; on one side are
attachment (moha), love, and on the other is our
chosen duty or dharma.
KNOW THY SELF?
Before we can fight the battle of
life we have know who we, the warriors, are. What is our
true self? Krishna advises Arjuna that our real self is
atma. While the body or adhibhuta is
perishable (adhi bhutam ksharo bhavah),
(7.4) the adhidaiva or atma, indweller
(dehi), is eternal, indestructible and constant
(dehi nityam avadhyah). (2.30). This
indestructible atma is bound to the body with the
three gunas (14.5). (Satvam rajas tam iti
gunah prakriti sambhava. Ni bandhanti dehe dehinam
avyayam.) All of us are born with these gunas
that determine our innate temperaments. We are driven to
act by this temperament. Even a wise man acts according
to his own nature; beings follow nature, what can
restraint do. (3.33) (sadrisham cheshte swasya
prakritae) People act wrongly driven by the
gunas. (3.37) When Arjuna asks Krishna "What
motivates people to wrong-doing?" Krishna replies
that born of passion (rajas), desire (kaam)
clouds the mind and intellect (aavritam gyanum),
as dust covers the mirror. This unappeasable fire of
desire is the constant foe of the wise and by
controlling one’s senses one should destroy this
constant foe of knowledge and spiritual realization.
In chapter 14 the author describes
the characteristics of the three gunas, or the
three types of temperaments: sattva, rajas, and
tamas. Saatvic leads to joy and knowledge;
rasasic to passion and desires; and tamasic
to ignorance and inertia. The concept is similar to the
concept of infant temperament postulated by
psychiatrists, Stella Chess and Alexander Thomas.
Saatvic person has easy
temperament. His attributes are: fearlessness,
fortitude, vigor, self-control, non-violence, truth,
freedom from anger, renunciation, tranquility,
aversion to fault finding, compassion, freedom from
covetousness, gentleness, modesty, and absence of
fickleness or impulsivity, and freedom from
excessive pride.
Raajasic is passionate,
desirous, arrogant, ostentatious, highly reactive
and active, intense — an A-type personality.
Taamasic is, lazy,
ignorant, deluded, and procrastinator.
NATURE OF GOD WHOM WE ARE SEEKING
Through the allegory of the external battlefield of
Kurukshetra, the author moves to the battlefield of
adhyatma, the inner self. He describes the relation
between atma, the individual or phenomenal self,
with the universal self, or the Brahmana. God a field of
unlimited potential and underlying beauty of everything
that is good in this world. "I am the good sweet smell
of moistened earth, the fire’s red light, and the vital
air (prana) in all that is moving." This
reminds one of Kena Upanishad in which the teacher tells
his students that Atman is the ear of the ear, the mind
of the mind, the speech of the speech, and prana
of the prana, and eye of the eye. God cannot be
seen or heard, but has to be experienced in the beauty
of whatever is excellent in this world. He is the smell
in the rose, He is the melody of the lyric, and He is
the intelligence of the genius (budhir budhimatam
asmi). He cannot be known by sense organs, but
through every mental act – pratibodhaviditam.
In chapter 7. 4 he describes that He consists of
lower self and a higher self. The lower self has 5 gross
elements, 5 subtle elements, and mind, intellect, and
ego. The higher self is the atma and adhyatma or
parmatma. From the lower self are born the multiple
jivas.
PURPOSE OF LIFE He proclaims that the union (yoga
- yoke or union) of this individual self with the
universal self is the purpose or summum bonum of
life. The purpose of life is to know and develop our
true self. This is Hindu dharma, process of knowing and
developing our real self – true upaasana
and true spirituality. He describes many approaches to
this self realization and union, depending upon the
temperament or svabhav of the person: pursuit of
knowledge for a contemplative person (gyan yogen
samkhya naam) and pursuit of action for an
active person (karma yogen yogi naam).
The path of knowledge,
Of selfless actions,
Of contemplation, meditation and
yoga, and
Of devotion
Detached or Selfless action (Performing Assigned Duty
without Regard for Results)
Krishna, then, expounds the theory of
detached action that is summarized in the following
verse:
Karmanya vaa dhika raste, maa phalesu
kadaachana
maa karma phal hetur bhurma, te sango
astv akarmane
"Thy right is to work alone, but
never to the fruits of work;
Let not the rewards of action be thy
motive, nor you be attached to inaction."
Krishna tells Arjuna that one should
work for work’s sake, for the sake of assigned duty, or
dharma, and not for the results. It may be argued that
results are the prime motivators of action and that
everyone works to achieve desired results. But according
to Krishna, one should be motivated by his or her
assigned duty (dharma), and not by expected results.
"Let right deeds be your motive, not
the fruit that comes from them."
Assigned duty, according to Krishna,
is determined by the stage of life (ashrama) and
chosen vocation (varna). The four stages of life
are: student until the age of 25, household from 25-50,
philanthropist from 50-75, a recluse from the age of
75-100. The assigned duty of a student is to study and
that of a household is to earn money by righteous means
to take care of his house. This concept of duty is
similar to the Kantian categorical imperative – action
driven by an internal sense of duty, not by inclinations
or as a mere means to achieve a desired end. One can
achieve the most exalted state of union with God (yoga)
by performing her/his assigned duty diligently and
efficiently — Yogah karmasu koshalam.
Obsession with results is
counterproductive because the outcome of actions is
determined by external forces, both known and unknown —
the unknown forces maybe called luck or the hand of God.
One who is obsessed with the results cannot apply his
undivided energies to the task at hand. Last but not the
least, desire for the results, if thwarted, causes
anger, anger results in loss of memory and loss of
memory, in turn, leads to loss of intelligence.
Detachment:
Krishna extols the virtues of
detachment from sensory and sensual pleasures. One who
is always seeking pleasures of the senses cannot be wise
and steadfast in his work. "He is driven like a
rudderless boat by the winds of desire. He cannot
contemplate, and without contemplation there is no peace
and without peace there is no joy."
He (sa) who gives up
all the desires (vihaya kamanya sarvan),
moves about without attachment (pumamshcharti
nispriha), and does not have thoughts of I or
mine (nirmamo nirahankarah), gains peace
(shantim adhi gacchati).
A person who is satisfied in the
self, by the Self (atmanyeva atmana), is
called a person of steady wisdom (stitha prajnast
adochyate). A person of steady wisdom
does not depend upon external contingencies for
happiness, is not shaken by adversity; is free from
infatuation, fear, and anger, has controlled his senses,
and remains emotionally balanced in pain and pleasure,
gain and loss, and victory and defeat. (Sukh dukhe
samai kritva labha labhau jaya jayau).
This ascetic ideal of stoicism is a
common staple of the higher ethics of all religions, but
it is impossible to achieve for most of us. Krishna is
showing us the ideal, to be happy just because it is the
true nature of the self to be happy, and not depend upon
the fulfillment of desires. Although desires act as the
engines of our actions we should stay calm if our
desires are not fulfilled. Otherwise we will be
frustrated and angry if they are not fulfilled and anger
causes loss of memory and judgment.
The Virtues of Action (Karma)
Chapter 3 begins with a question by
Arjuna — is knowledge better than action? Krishna
replies that there are two ways of living: pursuit of
knowledge for a contemplative person (gyan yogen
samkhya naam) and pursuit of action for an
active person (karma yogen yogi naam).
Neither renunciation nor mere knowledge lead to
perfection unless both are accompanied by selfless and
righteous actions performed without the desire for
rewards. He tells Arjuna that one cannot stop working
even for a moment, because work is the nature of man. He
advises Arjuna to perform his assigned duty (Niyatam
kuru karma tvam), because action is better than
inaction (karma jyayo hya akarmanah). The
forces of nature drive a man to work all the time, but
the work should be detached from the results (asakata),
and performed because it is one’s duty and not because
it is going to yield this or that result. The chosen
vocation in life (svadharmaa) should be
performed as a sacrifice or yagna, surrendering
the results to the judgement of god. One should not
dwell mentally upon sensual pleasures while at work. By
working thus, one can attain perfection and set example
for others to emulate. This work ethic of selfless
action is the highest ideal (karma-yoga).
Krishna teaches Arjuna about the
hierarchy of excellence — "Better than flesh are the
senses, better than senses is the mind, better than mind
is intellect, and better than intellect is the soul.
Therefore, listen to your intellect and soul."
Path of True Knowledge (Of Renunciation of Action)
CHAPTER 4
In this chapter, Krishna describes
the path of true knowledge, not worldly knowledge, but
spiritual knowledge (gyan yoga). Declaring
that nothing on this earth is as purifying as wisdom
(Na hi gyanen sadrisham pavitramiha vidyate),
He tells Arjuna that selfless actions are good but
better still are selfless actions performed
knowledgeably and wisely. Free from fear (bhaya),
passion (vitraag), and anger (krodha), one
should take refuge in God. In other words, one should
perform one’s chosen work without fear, passion, anger
and envy and be content with whatever reward he gets
from God for his actions. Chose your vocation from the
four vocations created by God according to your innate
temperaments. Then follow your chosen vocation as a
sacrifice (yagna), do not waver whether
you get pain or pleasure, or success or failure. Many
people offer material sacrifices to God, but fruitless
actions done wisely are the best oblation to the Lord. A
person who resolutely follows this path without any
doubts achieves supreme peace. Just as fire reduces wood
into ashes, this wisdom reduces all "actions" to ashes.
By "actions" the author means the rewards and
punishments of actions that force the individual soul to
return to this world. Thus when these attachments will
be destroyed the soul will be liberated form the cycle
of birth and death.
This chapter also contains the famous
exhortation of Krishna that he appears (incarnates
Himself) as Man to liberate the world from injustice (adharma)
whenever, the world is saturated with evil. This is a
contradiction because later the author says that God is
always with us, pervading, whatever is in this world. He
is limitless, then, why, He has to embody Himself.
Perhaps the author wants to say that a messiah or a
prophet is born whenever the world becomes vicious and
is on the brink of moral collapse.
Path of Renunciation (Sanyasa) CHAPTER 5
In this chapter Krishna
reconciles the two paths to salvation: the path of
renunciation (sanyasa) and the path of selfless
action (tyaga-yoga). He says that one cannot
become a recluse (sanayasi) or a yogi just by
giving up his home and work, but only by doing his duty
without expecting any reward. To the unwise these two
paths appear distinct, but in fact they are integrated.
The sanyasa or renunciation is the renunciation
of the fruits of actions (karma phalam tyaktava),
not renunciation of assigned duty. Therefore, one should
perform the assigned duty with pure intentions (vishudha
atma), controlling the senses (vijit atma
jitendriya), and in the spirit of yoga
(yoga yukto), duty for duty’s sake
God does not determine what you do,
nor is He the agent or doer, nor does He create the
desire for results. People do it themselves according to
their nature or svabahva. It means that the
people are responsible for their actions and they cannot
blame God or fate for what they do.
Path of Meditation and Contemplation CHAPTER 6
The responsibility of raising oneself
is one’s own. Men should raise themselves (Uddhared
atmana tmanam) instead of degrading themselves.
This can be done by performing your duty with devotion
and forgoing the desires and the imagery that goes with
actions (samkalpa). Only then the mind is
steadfast in action.
The mind can be made steadfast by
meditation as well. Sit in a clean quiet place with
head, neck, and back straight, focus either on the tip
of nose or in between the two eyes, regulate breathing
evenly between inspiration and expiration and the two
nostrils, and meditate upon the monsyllabic word Aum. Be
temperate in eating and recreation and practice yoga
with perseverance.
When the mind, restrained and refined
by the practice of concentration becomes steady and
attains serenity, one is satisfied in his own self, that
is, does not depend upon external contingencies for
happiness. Such a yogi sees the same awareness or God in
everything and everyone (yo maam pashyati sarvatra).
The highest yogi judges the pleasure and pain in
everyone with the same standard he applies to himself
(atmoupamyen sarvatra sam pashyati) or, in
other words, is happy in others’ happiness
and feels the pain of others as his own.
This concept of immanent God, the
same spark of divinity that is present in all, is the
basic precept of Raja Yoga. Much enmity will disappear
from this world if we can consider that our perceived
enemy has the same energy inspiring him, or we see the
same spark of divinity in him as in us.
The Highest Knowledge (Raaj Vidya or Raaj Yoga)
CHAPTER 9
God pervades whatever is in this
world in an unmanifest form that is a form that cannot
be appreciated by the senses. Although all beings abide
in Me I do not dwell in them. I am like a receptacle in
which all beings reside or I am like the sky (akasha)
in which all winds blow. At the end of a cosmic era (kalpa)
all beings go to God and at the beginning of time God
animates nature (prakriti) to create more beings.
Some people worship God as one (aikatven), some
as distinct from nature and the soul (prithaktven),
and some in various forms (bahuda vishvayto mukham).
Those who worship God in His unmanifest and non-separate
(ananya) form get salvation (moksha), even
those who worship other gods with devotion (shraadha),
worship Me (God) but wrongly (yajante maam a vidhi
purva kam). Worshipers of the minor gods go the
minor gods (devas), but those who worship Me come
to Me directly.
Whatever one does one should do as an
offering to God, without undue attachment to the
results.
The Lord says that all beings are
same to Him: (Samo aham sarva bhuteshu), I
am impartial, no one is especially hateful and no one is
especially dear to me.
Even if the greatest sinner worships
me he should be considered righteous for his righteous
resolve. Thus in this chapter, Krishna gives hope of
redemption to sinners, though in an earlier chapters he
had warned them that they will have to bear the fruits
of their sinful actions. Those who worship Me with
devotion, whether brahmanas, shudras, or women, abide in
me.
But Krishna cautions Arjuna that it
is not easy to achieve this state of equanimity, because
the mind is restless and turbulent by nature, and has to
be tamed by discipline (chanchal hi manah).
If the state of perfection in yoga is not achieved in
this life time (yoga sam sidhhi aprapya),
then one will be born in the home of the pure and
prosperous and will have a head start in his yogic
achievement in the next life. Thus yogic perfection will
be achieved in many births (anek janma sam sidhhis
tatoh yati paraam gatim) through constant
practice (abhyaasa) with detachment
(vairagya).
PATH OF DEVOTION
Devotion or bhakti is also a
path to salvation, but one has be a right type of
devotee. Among the four types of devotees in this world
- one in distress (artah), one who wants
to achieve some material thing (arthaarthi),
one who truly desires to know me (jigyasu),
and one who already knows me (gyani) – the
jigyasu and gyani are true devotees. The
gyani knows that the Lord is the essence of every
thing that is in this world (bijam ma sarva
bhutanam).
The Lord also says that those of
little understanding worship gods (devas)
other than Him with this or that rite to achieve this or
that desire, but the fruit of these men of little
understanding is limited. The foolish regard Him, the
unmanifest (avyaktam), as manifest (vyaktim).
These deluded men do not know that He is unborn (ajam)
and immutable (avyayam). Throughout Gita, the
author extols God as unmanifest or avayaktam and
yet contemporary Hinduism is steeped in the worship of
the manifest God.
PREREQUISITE FOR SPIRITUAL JOURNEY (ETHICS) CHAPTER
12
Although there are different paths to
God, the seeker (narah) has to first
develop the characteristics of a person who is dear
(priyo) to the Lord, as given below.
Free from hatred for any creature
(adveshta sarva bhutanaam)
Friendly and compassionate
(maitrah karun ava cha)
Free from the idea of "mineness
and egoism (nirmamo nir ahankar)
Even-minded and forbearing in
pain and pleasure (sama dukhah sukhah ksami)
Content, ever steady in
contemplation (santushtah satatam yogi)
Self-controlled and with a firm
resolve (yatatma drid nishchaya)
With mind and intellect
surrendered to the Lord (Mayi arpita mano
budhhih)
Does not disturb the world and is
undisturbed by it (yasmat na udvijate loko
loka na udvijate cha yah)
Free from joy, envy, fear, and
anxiety (harsha amirsha bhayo udvaigayi muktah)
Free from expectation/dependence,
pure, prompt (un apekshah, shuchir, daksha)
Dispassionate, phlegmatic,
renouncing (udasinah, gatvaythah, sarva arambh
parityagi)
Who neither rejoices, nor hates,
nor grieves (yoh na hrishyati na dveshti, na
shochati), nor desires, renounces the
judgment of good and evil, and is full of devotion
(na kankshati, shubh ashubh parityagi,
bhaktimana)
Similar to friend and foe, same
in honor and dishonor (samah shatrau cha mitre,
maan apmaanayoh)
Similar in heat or cold and in
pleasure and pain (shitoshna, sukha dukheshu
samah)
Free from attachment, to whom
criticism and praise are the same (sang avi
varjitah, tulya ninda stutir)
Is silent, content with anything
(mauni, santushto yen kenchit)
Treats the whole world as his
home, even-minded, and full of devotion (aniketah,
sthirmati, bhaktirmaan)
Follows this eternal ethics
(dharma) with an abiding faith (shradhha)
in the Lord is his true devotee.
A similar list of virtuous traits is
given in the 10th chapter, when the author
says that all the desirable traits in human beings arise
from Him, such as: intellect (budhhi), knowledge
(gyan), non-delusion (asamohah),
forbearance (kshma), truth (satyam),
restraint (damah), calmness of mind (shamah),
happiness (sukham), fearlessness (abhayam),
non-violence (ahimsa), evenness (samata),
contentment (tushtih), austerity (tapah),
and liberality (daanam).
RECONCILING THE VARIOUS PATHS
The author describes a hierarchy of
the paths to God: Knowledge is better than blind
abhyasa (shreyo hi gyanam abhyasa agyanat),
meditation with knowledge is better than mere knowledge,
and meditation with renunciation of the fruits of
actions is the best. The author begins this chapter by
reiterating that one should meditate (pary upasate)
upon the unmanifest (avayaktam) and indefinable (anirdeshyam)
God with an even mind. However, the author admits that
meditating on the unmanifest is more difficult than
meditating upon the manifest.